Three-to-Five Year Chapter 13 Plans: Which Applies To You
One of the core obligations of filing for Chapter 13 bankruptcy is that the debtor, the individual filing for bankruptcy protection, must file a repayment plan that tells all appropriate parties who is going to be paid, how much they are going to be paid and over what time period they are going to be paid. One significant question that arises when a Chapter 13 plan is being developed is how long it can and must last. To understand this effectively, you must understand a few other elements of the Bankruptcy Code.
We start with the Current Monthly Income test found in Form 122C of the bankruptcy petition. The Current Monthly Income test, commonly referred to simply as the CMI, looks at all of the actual income that a household received in the six calendar months prior to the expected filing date of a bankruptcy petition. Most sources of income are included, though there are some very specific exclusions. The six-month total income is then divided by six to get a monthly average, then annualized by multiplying the monthly average by 12. This annualized amount is then compared to the Internal Revenue Service published median income amount for the jurisdiction based on the household size. There are two very important results that come from this calculation.
If the annualized income is higher than the IRS median income figure (over-median):
- A presumption arises that the individual is not eligible to file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection and can only seek bankruptcy protection under another chapter, usually Chapter13.
- If the individual elects to file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, then they are required to propose a five-year repayment plan unless they can pay all of their outstanding debts in a shorter period of time and elect to do so.
If the annualized income is lower than the IRS median income figure (under-median):
- The individual may elect whether to file for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Which option is appropriate depends on the details of the individual’s financial circumstances.
- If the individual elects to file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy protection, then they are permitted to propose a repayment plan that only has a three-year duration. They still can propose a longer plan, up to five years, to make the economics of the plan work, but are not required to. They can only propose a plan term under three years if it will pay all of their outstanding debts in that time.
Over-median debtors are then required to complete a second math problem, known as the Disposable Monthly Income test, or DMI. This allows for the calculated income to be offset by a series of allowable expenses, some based on IRS figures, others based on actual expenses of the debtor. At the end of the calculation, if the individual has little to no disposable income left over, they will have effectively rebutted the presumption that they cannot file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and can elect the bankruptcy chapter that is most appropriate for them. If that is Chapter 13, then the DMI calculation means that there is no minimum amount of unsecured debt that they have to pay in the plan due to their prior income. If there is a substantial amount of disposable income left over after the DMI calculation, then the individual cannot file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in most cases (there are always exceptions) and they will be required to pay a minimum amount to unsecured creditors based on the DMI.
That covers the statutory determination of the required length of a Chapter 13 plan. Now let’s discuss the practical reasons. Over-median debtors file five-year bankruptcy plans in the vast majority of cases. They could file a shorter plan to pay all of their debts in less time, but why would they? The payment would, by definition, be lower over the five years and they can always pay it off early. More often, over-median debtors engage in the exercise of minimizing their payments over the required five-year period to meet the minimum DMI-required payment. This is where the guidance of an experienced bankruptcy attorney helps significantly, as they have a good understanding of what the court would allow as reasonable and necessary expenses and know how to make the appropriate arguments.
Under-median debtors also often file five-year repayment plans, even though they are only required to propose a three-year minimum term plan. The reason is pretty obvious. The longer the plan lasts, the lower the plan payment can be and many people in bankruptcy need the lowest payment possible to succeed. Since they are under-median, there is no mandatory distribution to unsecured creditors driven by the DMI. Most debtors do not have any assets of value that exceed their allowable exemptions, so that does not mandate any meaningful distribution to unsecured creditors. Realistically, they need more time in repayment because the mortgage arrears, balance on the car, tax debt, etc. must be paid in the plan, ordinary expenses like food, gas and insurance must be paid to live and the longer plan they propose, the lower the monthly payment is.
Chapter 13 bankruptcy is hard. More than half that are filed do not reach completion and discharge. I personally filed hundreds of cases over my practice career with razor-thin budgets that did not make it through. They were filed because it was the only realistic chance that the debtor had to keep their home or vehicle and deal with their other debts. Chapter 13 bankruptcies filed without the assistance of counsel have almost no chance of succeeding. They are simply too complicated, with too many rules, requirements and nuances. If it seems like Chapter 13 bankruptcy is a reasonable option for you, consult with an experienced bankruptcy attorney in your area. Most will offer free consultations and put the majority of their fees into your repayment plan. The value their assistance will far exceed the cost.